Tom Sawyer, whitewashing fences, and building communities online

I spoke on a panel at GE today with Chris Brogan, author of the book Trust Agents (almost finished with it, more comments in a later post…).

Tom Sayer sez everyone's fence gets whitewashed today, people!

Tom Sawyer sez everyone's fence gets whitewashed today, people!

After hearing Chris talk about building trust in online communities, it hit me that one of the biggest mistakes I’ve seen people make when trying to build communities online, even in the open source world, is that they think like Tom Sawyer.

Here’s how Wikipedia retells the story of Tom Sawyer and the fence:

After playing hooky from school on Friday and dirtying his clothes in a fight, Tom is made to whitewash the fence as punishment on Saturday. At first, Tom is disappointed by having to forfeit his day off. However, he soon cleverly persuades his friends to trade him small treasures for the privilege of doing his work.

When thinking about building communities online, are you thinking like Tom Sawyer? Why are you building a community in the first place? When it comes right down to it, do you really just want people to whitewash your fence for you and give you small treasures in return for the privilege?

If you are looking to ideas like open source or social media as simple means to get what you want for your company, it’s time to rethink your community strategy.

I’ve talked to people at companies who are considering “open sourcing” their product because they think there is an army of people out there who will jump at the chance to build their products for them. Many of these people go on to learn tough but valuable lessons in building community. It’s not that simple.

You can avoid the Tom Sawyer trap through some exercises in humility. A couple of questions for you: Why does it have to be your community and why do you have to build it? Do people have to come participate in your community, or might you consider joining their community?

When we crafted the new Red Hat Mission (watch the video below to learn more about it or read this post), we considered the wording around community very carefully. Here’s how it reads:

To be the catalyst in communities of customers, contributors, and partners creating better technology the open source way.

Note that we don’t ever claim we own the communities. And we don’t take credit for creating them. In most cases we didn’t. We just want to be in them (in being the key word), and we want to use our brand, our experience, our people, and our resources to be a catalyst in these communities… a catalyst for good work we (and our customers and partners) want to see done.

We participate, bringing the resources of a successful open source business, and stuff happens. Who cares who “owns” the community when everyone gets what they want?

Avoid the Tom Sawyer trap. Your customers are not as gullible as Tom’s friends were, and they won’t trust your motives unless they see what is in it for them as (or more) clearly than they see what’s in it for you.

Rather than asking how they can paint your fence for you, ask yourself how can we all paint everyone’s fences together?

You’ll change everything if you take yourself out of the center of the community and instead become a humble contributor to a community where everyone, including you, will benefit from your efforts.

Was this post helpful?

If so, you can find more tips about how to build your brand effectively in my book, The Ad-Free Brand (not an advertisement, mind you, just a friendly suggestion:).

Only $9.99 for the Kindle, but available in each of these formats:
| Kindle | Nook | EPUB/PDF

About Chris Grams

Chris Grams is Head of Marketing at Tidelift. He is also the author of The Ad-Free Brand: Secrets to Successful Brand Positioning in a Digital World.


18 thoughts on “Tom Sawyer, whitewashing fences, and building communities online

  1. You have to be one of the biggest participants in the community to make it a success. I tell all community managers and those interested in becoming one that you have to be prepared to contribute the most and have the most passion about the community. Sure, influencers will come, people will embrace the community and treat it as their own. That’s great. But those people can go just as easily as they come and that is what we must be mindful of. So even if you do somehow get people to paint your fence, so to speak…chancess are they won’t finish the job. Good post.
    Angela Connor
    Author, “18 Rules of Community Engagement”

    Posted by Angela Connor | September 9, 2009, 8:31 am
    • Thanks Angela! And thanks for the thoughts– based on my experiences, I’d agree completely– passion is at the heart of any successful community, and passion is something that it is very hard to fake…

      Posted by cdgrams | September 10, 2009, 12:59 pm
    • Painting everyone’s fences is an act of cooperation. People in the community needs to help one another for them to live with harmony. This article should be spread all over the place so that people will be enlighten.

      Posted by Wilma | May 30, 2012, 3:00 am


  1. Pingback: Tom Sawyer, whitewashing fences, and building communities online · Video Beijing - September 9, 2009

  2. Pingback: Twitted by paulsalazar - September 9, 2009

  3. Pingback: Twitter Trackbacks for Tom Sawyer, whitewashing fences, and building communities online « Dark Matter Matters [] on - September 9, 2009

  4. Pingback: Small Powerful Words - September 10, 2009

  5. Pingback: Small Powerful Words » Become eVOLVE'd - September 11, 2009

  6. Pingback: The difference between collaboration and clobberation « Dark Matter Matters - September 23, 2009

  7. Pingback: Tom Sawyer Part 2: where can your company pitch in? « Dark Matter Matters - October 13, 2009

  8. Pingback: Maslow’s hierarchy of (community) needs « Dark Matter Matters - November 3, 2009

  9. Pingback: Safe as Milk » Blog Archive » The trough of disillusionment for Ubuntu? - November 5, 2009

  10. Pingback: Dave Neary: The trough of disillusionment for Ubuntu? | - November 6, 2009

  11. Pingback: Top 10 Dark Matter Matters posts of 2009 « Dark Matter Matters - December 21, 2009

  12. Pingback: Open Source community building: a guide to getting it right | VisionMobile :: blog - January 5, 2011

  13. Pingback: How to build a open source community | Official Blog of Kevin Media - January 12, 2011

  14. Pingback: How to *really* help the communities your brand interacts with « Dark Matter Matters - October 7, 2011

  15. Pingback: Open Source community building: a guide to getting it right | DataTMT - December 22, 2012

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Hey, I Wrote a Book!

The Ad-Free Brand: Secrets to Building Successful Brands in a Digital World

Available now in print and electronic versions.

%d bloggers like this: